By Shashi Tharoor - Project Syndicate | May 5, 2025
Pakistan spent decades nurturing, sheltering, arming, training, and financing the Taliban, which it viewed as a convenient instrument for exerting control over Afghanistan and achieving “strategic depth” against India. But as Dr. Frankenstein discovered, you cannot always control the monsters you create.
NEW DELHI – The statement issued by Afghanistan’s Taliban government denouncing the recent terrorist attack in the Indian resort of Pahalgam, in Jammu and Kashmir, was eye-opening. The Ministry of Foreign Affairs conveyed condolences to the families of the overwhelmingly Indian victims – 26 civilians – emphasizing that such attacks jeopardize regional security. The implicit rebuke of the terrorists’ handlers in Pakistan has not gone unnoticed.
This is hardly the first sign of the Taliban’s growing estrangement from its erstwhile backers in Pakistan. In fact, by the end of last year, relations had deteriorated enough that Pakistan’s Special Representative for Afghanistan, Muhammad Sadiq Khan, headed to Kabul for talks with senior Taliban leaders, ostensibly to ease tensions. But while he was there, on December 24, the Pakistan Air Force carried out strikes against alleged Pakistani Taliban – officially known as the Tehrik-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) – targets in Afghanistan’s Paktika province, killing 46 people. The strike was viewed as retribution for a December 21 TTP attack that resulted in the deaths of 16 Pakistani soldiers.
Three days later, Lieutenant General Ahmed Sharif Chaudhry, who leads Pakistan’s Inter-Services Public Relations (ISPR) directorate, delivered a grim report: 383 officers and soldiers in Pakistan’s security forces had lost their lives in counter-terrorism operations over the preceding year. He also claimed that approximately 925 terrorists, including members of the TTP, had been eliminated in around 60,000 intelligence-based operations. The TTP, he pointed out, had been targeting Pakistan and its citizens, while enjoying a safe haven in Afghanistan.
The statement hung heavy with irony, given Pakistan’s long history of providing logistical, military, and moral support to both the Afghan Taliban and the associated Haqqani Network during their campaigns against the previous Afghan government and American forces, culminating in the Taliban’s return to power in Afghanistan in 2021. What a difference a few years makes. (It is worth noting that India does not officially recognize the Taliban as representing the Afghan people.)
On December 28, the conflict escalated further, with Afghanistan’s Ministry of Defense announcing, and claiming responsibility for, attacks on multiple locations inside Pakistan, in retaliation for the air strikes. Interestingly, the Afghan government refrained from explicitly acknowledging that it was targeting Pakistani territory, instead saying that attacks were being carried out beyond the “hypothetical line,” a reference to the colonial-era border, known as the Durand Line, which no Afghan government has recognized.
While things seem to have cooled off since then, the limits of Pakistan’s influence over its former proxies are now starkly apparent. Pakistan’s Inter-Services Intelligence agency spent decades nurturing, sheltering, arming, training, and financing the Taliban, which it used as a proxy of Pakistan’s security establishment. Though the Pakistani military was aware of a certain intransigence among the Taliban, it consistently treated the group as a means of exerting control over Afghanistan and achieving “strategic depth” against India. When the Afghan Taliban captured Kabul in August 2021, Pakistan celebrated with unconcealed glee.
But as Dr. Frankenstein discovered, you cannot always control the monsters you create. For Pakistan, neither coercion nor diplomacy has proved effective. The problem is that Pakistan’s military has been deemed insufficiently Islamist by the militants it has spawned. The TTP is now determined to do to Pakistan what its parent did to Afghanistan: take over the government and turn the country into an Islamist theocracy. And given their ideological affinities, the Afghan Taliban may well be helping the TTP pursue that goal.
Pakistan’s relationship with Afghanistan has become strategic quicksand. So deep is the quagmire that, under growing public pressure, segments of Pakistan’s government have suggested turning to the United States for assistance and even offering drone bases to the US to target militants in Afghanistan. The idea that sophisticated US drones and other weapons might help Pakistan confront an insurgency born from its own anti-American policies in Afghanistan is absurd. And yet, it is no longer unthinkable.
Pakistan’s army chief, General Asim Munir, embodies his country’s strategic confusion. An Islamist ideologue himself, he has urged the Afghan regime not to prioritize the TTP over their “long-standing and benevolent brother Islamic country.” But he also once stated, “When it comes to the safety and security of every single Pakistani, the whole of Afghanistan can be damned.”
The tensions between Afghanistan and Pakistan extend beyond cross-border terrorism; they are rooted in competing territorial claims and clashing national identities. The Afghan Taliban’s support for the TTP, coupled with persistent disputes over the Durand Line, stoke Pakistani fears of irredentism. The Pakistani government is withholding recognition of the Taliban-led regime in Kabul, while seeking tangible measures against the TTP, which continues to pose an existential threat to Pakistan’s stability and to the dominance of its military establishment.
Pakistan-Afghanistan tensions – rooted in historical grievances, fueled by misguided policies, and compounded by ideological conflict – are rising fast, with Afghanistan now serving not as a strategic asset for Pakistan, but as a grave liability. India must wait and watch how this drama on its western flank plays out.
Shashi Tharoor, a former UN under-secretary-general and former Indian Minister of State for External Affairs and Minister of State for Human Resource Development, is an MP for the Indian National Congress and Chairman of the Parliamentary Standing Committee on External Affairs. He was re-elected to the Lok Sabha for a fourth successive term, representing Thiruvananthapuram. He is the author, most recently, of Ambedkar: A Life (Aleph Book Company, 2022).
Copyright Project Syndicate
TIPP Takes
Geopolitics, Geoeconomics, And More
1. Trump-Putin Meeting Is Necessary, But No Specifics Yet: Kremlin - Reuters
Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov, asked by reporters about comments by Trump that he might consider meeting with Putin during a trip to Saudi Arabia this month, said the Kremlin chief had no trip there scheduled, but that “such a meeting is clearly on everyone’s lips.”
“And in many ways we think it is certainly necessary,” Peskov said. “It has to be prepared accordingly and it requires efforts at various expert levels,” including continued contacts between Moscow and Washington, he added. “But so far there are no specifics on this.”
2. Patriot Defense System Headed For Ukraine As Cease-Fire Hopes Dim - UPI
An Israel-based Patriot air defense system is being moved to Ukraine to help in its ongoing battle against a 3-year-long Russian invasion, officials announced.
The system will be sent after it is refurbished, and Western allies have said Germany and Greece could also send an additional one. The deployment is a continuation of the previous administration's commitment to send more defense weapons to Kyiv. Trump administration officials said "it continues to provide equipment to Ukraine from previously authorized" agreements, The New York Times reported.
3. Zelenskyy: Ceasefire 'Possible' The Moment Russia Agrees - D.W.
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said an interim ceasefire with Russia was possible any moment, "even starting today," if Moscow agreed to the U.S. proposal.
Zelenskyy's comments come hours after he rejected the Russian president's declaration of a three-day truce over May 8-10, denouncing it as a "theatrical show" that hardly allows time to hold talks to end the war. Zelenskyy also said earlier during those comments that Ukraine "cannot bear responsibility for what happens" to foreign leaders attending the World War II commemoration ceremony in Moscow on May 9.
4. China Risks A Spiral Into Deeper Deflation As It Diverts U.S.-Bound Exports To Domestic Market - CNBC
Local Chinese governments and major businesses have voiced support to help tariff-hit exporters redirect their products to the domestic market for sale.
JD.com, for instance, has pledged 200 billion yuan ($28 billion) to help exporters and has set up a dedicated section on its platform for goods originally intended for U.S. buyers, with discounts of up to 55%. As the trade war knocks down export orders, deflation in China’s wholesale prices will likely deepen to 2.8% in April, from 2.5% in March, according to a team of economists at Morgan Stanley.
5. Trump Says He Will Not Drop Tariffs To Get China To Negotiating Table - Fox News
The president discussed his stance on the tariffs, which he defended, in an interview with NBC's "Meet The Press" recorded Friday from his Mar-a-Lago estate.
"You're not dropping the tariffs against China to get them to the negotiating table?" host Kristen Welker asked. Trump responded, "No."
"At some point, I'm going to lower them, because otherwise you could never do business with them," he added later. "And they want to do business very much like their economy is really doing badly. Their economy is collapsing."
6. Vietnam Enters Fray At Disputed South China Sea Sandbank - RFA
Vietnam protested China and the Philippines over their competing activities at Sandy Cay in the disputed South China Sea, highlighting the country’s increasingly assertive voice in regional maritime disputes.
China and the Philippines last week staged rival flag-raising displays on Sandy Cay, a key site for Manila to monitor Chinese activity in the Philippines’ exclusive economic zone. Hanoi, which also considers the sandbank part of its territory, said that it had sent diplomatic notes to both China and the Philippines protesting their recent activities at the disputed site.
7. Israel Eyes Hostage Deal Window Ahead Of Trump Visit, Plans Gaza 'Conquest' - TIPP Insights
A senior Israeli defense official said there is a “window of opportunity” for a Gaza hostage deal ahead of President Donald Trump’s upcoming Middle East visit.
If no agreement is reached, Israel will launch “Operation Gideon Chariots,” an expanded campaign aimed at conquering Gaza and displacing hundreds of thousands of Palestinians to the south. The Israeli security cabinet approved the plan unanimously on Sunday, including a controversial framework for aid delivery — still unimplemented — as international criticism mounts.
8. Iran Warns U.S. Bases In Region Are Targets If Attacked, Unveils New Ballistic Missile - Al Arabiya
“If we are attacked – if a war is imposed on us – we will respond forcefully. We will target their interests and their bases,” Iran’s defense minister Aziz Nasirzadeh said in an interview with state TV.
Also on Sunday, Iran unveiled its latest ballistic missile, named “Qassem Basir,” according to the state-linked Tasnim news agency. “The Qassem Basir missile is a solid-fuel ballistic missile with a range of 1,200 kilometers (746 miles),” the agency reported.
9. No NATO Summit For Trump Unless Allies Boost Defense Spending - TIPP Insights
According to reports from Spiegel and Reuters, President Donald Trump may skip the upcoming NATO summit in the Netherlands this June unless European allies increase their defense spending.
Trump has long criticized NATO members, particularly Germany, for not meeting spending commitments, arguing that the United States unfairly bears the burden of the alliance’s defense costs. Last week, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth raised the issue with his German counterpart, urging accelerated defense investments.
10. Rwanda Confirms Talks With U.S. About Taking In Migrants - BBC
The East African country's Foreign Affairs Minister, Olivier Nduhungirehe’s comments come after Secretary of State Marco Rubio said last month that Washington was "actively searching" for countries that would take in "some of the most despicable human beings."
Nduhungirehe said the talks were "not new to us" as Rwanda had previously agreed to accept migrants deported by the UK. However, the UK abandoned the scheme, which faced numerous legal challenges, after Sir Keir Starmer's Labour government took office last July.
11. Mexico's President Rejects Trump Offer Of U.S. Troops To Fight Cartels - UPI
Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum, speaking at a function, addressed a report from the Wall Street Journal that said Trump had offered up troops during a lengthy phone call earlier this year.
"I want to say it's true; that, in some of the calls, but not in the way they mention it," Sheinbaum said in her speech. "And you know what I told him? 'No, President Trump, territory is inviolable, sovereignty is inviolable, sovereignty is not for sale; sovereignty is loved and defended.'"
12. Mercedes To Build New Model In Tuscaloosa To Deepen U.S. Ties - TIPP Insights
Mercedes-Benz announced it will begin production of a new “core segment” vehicle at its Tuscaloosa County, Alabama, plant in 2027, further anchoring its U.S. presence amid growing trade uncertainty.
While details on the new model were sparse, executives framed the move as a strategic shift to deepen ties with the U.S. market as Trump administration tariffs disrupt global supply chains.
13. Saudi Arabia Records $70.3 Billion In Revenue In Q1 2025 - Al Arabiya
Saudi Arabia’s finance ministry announced that total revenues for the first quarter of 2025 reached approximately 263.6 billion riyals ($70.3 billion). Of that, 149.8 billion riyals ($39.9 billion) came from oil revenues.
The figures come as the Kingdom continues its efforts to diversify income sources and strengthen long-term fiscal sustainability.
14. Warren Buffett Sends Wall Street a Grim $348 Billion Warning. History Says the Stock Market Will Do This Next. - The Motley Fool
Warren Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway reported a record $348 billion in cash, equivalents, and U.S. Treasury bills on its balance sheet as of March 31.
The $1.5 billion in net stock sales is also noteworthy. Berkshire has now been a net seller of stocks for 10 consecutive quarters. Since 2019, Berkshire Hathaway has been a net seller of stocks in 19 of 25 quarters. History says, the S&P 500 has typically performed worse following quarters in which Berkshire was a net seller.
15. Warren Buffett’s Anti-Crypto Stance May Have Changed — Here’s An Update - GOBankingRates
Although the digital currency is widely recognized and has had extraordinary moments like recently hitting $100,000 in value for the first time, Warren Buffett is not a fan. However, his company Berkshire Hathaway might be easing up on crypto. Here’s why.
In 2021, Berkshire Hathaway invested $500 million, followed by another $250 million in Nu Holdings, a Brazilian digital banking company Fortune reported. Berkshire Hathaway owns 433,558 shares of Jefferies Financial Group Inc., a financial services company, according to Benzinga.
16. Excessive Cinnamon May Interfere With Some Medications, Study Shows - HealthDay News
The study, published in the the journal Food Chemistry: Molecular Sciences, looked at how cinnamon and its key ingredients affect the way the body processes drugs, The Washington Post reported.
While small amounts of cinnamon can offer health benefits, researchers say using it too often or in high amounts may lead to drug interactions. Overuse of cinnamon could cause the body to clear some drugs too quickly, making them less effective, The Post reported. Cinnamon has become more popular in recent years, especially among people with type 2 diabetes.
